I’m a big believer in not letting the tax tail wag the dog, and nowhere does that tail wag harder than in estate planning during an election cycle. A question this week from a business-owning couple shows exactly why.
They’re in their late 60s with a net worth of around $22 million, most of it in a closely held manufacturing business they spent 30 years building. In 2024, worried about the scheduled sunset of the higher exemption, they used a big piece of it funding a spousal lifetime access trust (SLAT). Now their attorney tells them the exemption is permanent at $15 million but could drop to $3.5 million depending on the 2028 election. In their words: “We’re exhausted, we don’t want to give away too much and regret it. And we’re equally scared we’ll sit still and get crushed. How are we supposed to plan right now?”
Start With What You Need, Not What the Tax Code Might Do
Estate exemptions can feel urgent, but they’re really a next-generation problem. Goal number one is getting through retirement and the rest of your life without running out of money. Even if the estate tax were 80%, I’d still tell you the first step is figuring out how much you actually need to do everything you want to do before you give anything away.
The reason is in the name. An irrevocable gift can’t be revoked. Once that money moves out of your estate, it’s gone. I have the same hesitation when someone tells me they’re going to give to charity to save on taxes. Of course you’ll save on taxes; you’re giving the money away. You’re giving up a dollar to save 30 cents. Large estate gifts follow the same math.
Tax Law Doesn’t Change Overnight
Could the exemption drop from $15 million to $3.5 million? Absolutely. But we don’t know that it will, and even if it does, it’s very unlikely that a bill comes out on a Monday and the limit drops on Tuesday. Changes like this take time to move through Congress and into effect.
That lag is your planning window. If a real proposal starts moving, we can do exactly what you did a few years ago: evaluate the estate, decide whether there’s room to move more out, and use whatever higher exemption still exists before the change takes hold.
Reading the Timeline
The 2028 election is still two years away, and the current administration holds veto power until then, so wide-ranging estate tax changes before that point are very unlikely. If 2028 does bring a shift, think about how it plays out: an election in 2028, legislative decisions in 2029, and changes that likely take effect in 2030 or 2031.
A lot can happen in that stretch. The stock market could double. It could also fall by half. Your business could grow, or you could sell it. Making an irreversible decision today based on where your estate might stand five years from now means guessing at almost every input.
The Exemption Isn’t the Only Proposal on the Table
I don’t want to downplay the uncertainty. There are a lot of proposals being tossed around right now, from higher top marginal rates to a lower estate limit. For a manufacturer, depreciation matters too. The bonus depreciation rules that have been very favorable to businesses over the past few years could change or go away.
Do I think taxes go up? Probably. We’re at historically low tax rates and historically high national debt, and those two facts together point toward higher rates and lower exemptions at some point. But we don’t know that yet, and “probably, at some point” is a weak reason to make a gift you can never take back.
Keeping Every Option Open Until 2028
This isn’t an argument against planning. It’s an argument that you have time to plan well. For now, holding off on new irrevocable gifts preserves the most optionality, and optionality is worth protecting when the decisions on the table are permanent. That still means working through the numbers with us, your advisors, and getting your attorneys’ opinions on the specific structures available to you.
The practical step this year is the one that comes before any gifting: build a spending and cash flow projection that shows what the two of you need for the rest of your lives, including what the business provides, and treat only what sits above that line as available for future gifts. We also just sent a letter to our clients walking through the current proposals and how likely we think each one is. Sign up for the Scholar newsletter and you’ll receive a copy directly.
This post is adapted from a recent episode of the Scholar Wealth Podcast. For more perspective on estate exemption planning while tax proposals are still in flux, watch the full podcast episode here.